6 Comments
User's avatar
TGGP's avatar

It took me a while to find Kaleberg's comment over at Noah's. It's here:

https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/on-the-wisdom-of-the-historians/comment/8663079

Expand full comment
David Hugh-Jones's avatar

I couldn’t find the link. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Ro'i's avatar

I agree with almost everything. I often discuss with students the issue of the study of patterns vs. study of particular events when discussing the history of experimental economics. I do not agree with one thing. You doing calculations in your head do deserve public funding. Well, maybe you should think about social science and genetics, but mathematicians solving non-practical problems should continue doing that, as do scholars of Assyrian texts or what have you.

Expand full comment
David Hugh-Jones's avatar

I mean, I'm literally talking about "hmm, what's 45 x 69?"

Expand full comment
Razib Khan's avatar

Smith not Feldman

Expand full comment
David Hugh-Jones's avatar

Oops! Thank you.

Expand full comment